Analysis
Jobs Outperform – Dissecting the Numbers and What That Means for You
The raw numbers: Employment increased by 162,000 in August, well above the forecasted 56,000. The unemployment rate held steady at 4.1%, and the labor force participation rate ticked up slightly to 61.6% though it’s still half a point below where it stood a year ago. The biggest gains came from food service (+59,000) and local government education (+42,000), though with education hires in August, we’d take that number with a grain of salt given seasonal noise. Most other industries showed the steady growth we’ve come to expect, with one notable exception: information employment. That sector covers computing infrastructure, publishing, and broadcasting, and the decline there is likely tied to AI giving individuals more direct capability to do work that used to require larger teams. As we mentioned yesterday, this remains a transitional period for industries most exposed to AI adoption.
If history is any guide, we should be a little skeptical of a 162K gain, the Bureau of Labor Statistics has a track record of overestimating job growth, only to revise it down later once no one’s paying attention. That said, we’re cautiously optimistic here. The last three months came in modest, and the trailing year of data has been choppy across the board. Revisions to the prior two months were also modest, which gives us some reason to think this report might hold up better than most.
Assuming the numbers are roughly accurate, here’s how this plays into our two main areas of focus.
First, the Federal Reserve.
The Fed has signaled it’s not cutting the funds rate anytime soon, and some are speculating a hike is on the table, maybe not this month, but possibly before year-end. Rate cuts are typically used to support employment once inflation looks under control. Fed Chair Warsh made clear at his Jackson Hole address that inflation remains his primary focus, which points toward a hold at the upcoming meeting. From there, the Fed will be watching the data closely ahead of the following scheduled meeting on October 27-28. The one thing that could tip the scale toward a hike at the September meeting is a hotter-than-expected inflation report next Friday.
Second, mortgage rates.
Rates ticked up slightly on the report, about 0.05%, practically nothing. That’s the typical pattern: good economic news tends to nudge rates up because it’s driven by investor behavior. Traders treat mortgages as an investment, and when the economic outlook is strong, money tends to flow toward the stock market and other higher-risk, higher-return options. That means mortgage-backed securities have to offer a slightly better return to stay competitive. In recessionary periods, it works the opposite way, investors move toward safe havens like Treasuries and mortgages, which pushes rates down.
These day-to-day moves are minor compared to the bigger trend, though. As we’ve said before, mortgage rates ultimately follow inflation. A solid jobs report gives us some confidence that the Fed will stay focused on bringing inflation down which, over time, is what actually helps mortgage rates move lower.
Common questions
Are there other reports that affect rates day to day?
Yes, just about anything economic related. The main ones are inflation and jobs reports, those move rates the most. But GDP numbers, trade deals, conflicts, oil prices, all can have an affect on rates, and will make them move on the day that they’re released.
How much do rates move daily?
Not much, usually less than 1/10th of a point. These reports tend to move rates as little as 0.02% but can be as high as 0.25%. That’s a single day movement, if we have an overarching trend in one way on these reports that is where we may see slight movement each day but over the course of several weeks we see considerable movement.
But inflation has the biggest affect?
Yes, in the long run inflation is the trend setter. Inflation is the reason rates haven’t moved any higher. You may have seen the term “Mortgage Spreads” some lately. That’s the relation of the 10 year treasury yield to the average mortgage rate. That spread is tighter than normal because inflation has been steady and has pulled rates down closer to the 10 year.