Analysis

Open Real Estate formed by 4 Real Estate Giants

UPDATED BY J. CHARLES LENDING TREC CE PROVIDER 11343-CEP READ 15 MIN

In this episode

Four of the largest real estate companies in the country announced ⁠Open Real Estate⁠, a shared listing platform that any brokerage can join for free.

We discuss some potential benefits and some fallout that could have massive affects for the real estate industry moving forward.

Listen

Show notes

The founders are AGNT Inc. (the parent of eXp Realty), Keller Williams, Real REMAX Group and HomeServices of America. It’s their answer to Compass, the largest brokerage in the country, which markets some homes privately inside its own network before they ever reach the MLS.

Our take: more ways to market a home is good for buyers and sellers. But for most houses, getting in front of every possible buyer right away still wins. Private testing makes the most sense for unique properties, sellers who need privacy, and sellers whose price expectations are ahead of the market..

The part worth repeating

This is the real question. Is a seller better off quietly testing a price, or putting the home in front of every possible buyer on day one? For roughly 98% of homes, we think it’s the second one. More buyers means more competition, and more competition is what gets a typical house its best price.

Common questions

What is the potential fallout?

Is this the beginning of the end for NAR and the MLS? Here’s where the snowball could become an avalanche. On one side you have the largest brokerage in the country. On the other, the next four largest, open to everyone else. Strip it down and the MLS is a place to find homes for sale, and Zillow mostly republishes what’s on it. If a network that big starts holding most listings, the MLS starts to look like a duplicate, and so do the MLS and NAR dues that come with it.

Mentioned in this episode

Read the full transcript

(0:03) All right, welcome back to the Beyond the Rate podcast. (0:05) Charlie and Will here going beyond the rate (0:07) to discuss news and market forces (0:09) that affect real estate and mortgage. (0:11) We have quite a few things that are going on this week.(0:15) As far as the mortgage side is concerned, (0:18) been pretty stable the last few days. (0:20) We got a little bit of a rally, (0:22) pretty stable on that front. (0:25) We do have Fed meeting going on right now, right? (0:30) And we’re going to really analyze (0:34) the commentary of the Fed meeting, (0:36) not necessarily the Fed decision.(0:39) And then we have GDP and an inflation report (0:42) coming out Thursday. (0:43) So we’ll get into that more later in the week. (0:48) But pretty big news came out yesterday and then today.(0:56) Who is the group? (0:57) Pretty interesting. (0:59) So basically what Compass has done (1:03) is they’ve created what’s called the private exclusive, (1:06) which is essentially showing being able to market a house (1:12) without it hitting the MLS, okay? (1:15) So they market it inside their ecosystem, all right? (1:20) And now Compass, they purchased several (1:25) other real estate firms over the last couple of years. (1:28) So now they are, right? (1:29) They’re the largest.(1:30) They’re the largest, yep. (1:31) In the country. (1:32) Yeah, and- (1:32) So they have the bandwidth, if we will, to do that.(1:36) Yeah. (1:36) Yeah. (1:37) And so the second- (1:41) Yeah, just say it again.(1:42) Yeah. (1:43) So the second, third, fourth, and fifth largest groups (1:48) are forming what they’re calling Open Real Estate. (1:51) It’s a platform- (1:52) Oh, okay.(1:53) That is going to compete (1:55) with the Compass private exclusive, all right? (2:00) So let’s- (2:03) And this was all released yesterday, right? (2:06) Yeah. (2:07) It was yesterday. (2:07) Several platforms already interviewed them.(2:11) Yeah, it is eXp, Keller Williams, (2:17) RealRemax, and Home Services of America. (2:23) There you go, yep. (2:25) So, yes.(2:27) Wow. (2:28) So we were trying to, we were just discussing this. (2:32) Now, basically, yeah.(2:38) Go ahead. (2:38) First, it’s funny how it’s all kind of (2:43) been a chain reaction. (2:44) Several years ago, they had that (2:45) National Association of Realtors lawsuit (2:49) about representation and whatnot.(2:52) Keller Williams was part of that settlement. (2:54) Can’t remember if Remax was or not. (2:58) I personally think that NAR, (3:00) National Association of Realtors, (3:02) NAR just kind of caved or folded.(3:03) I thought they could have fought harder. (3:07) But I think that it’s all kind of snowballed off of that. (3:13) And now, obviously, to be a quote-unquote realtor, (3:17) you have to be a member (3:20) of the National Association of Realtors.(3:22) They have all these rules now (3:23) about by representations and whatnot. (3:26) Then came some fights between Compass and Zillow (3:33) where this is the second part of the snowball, right? (3:37) So the snowball is getting bigger. (3:39) And Compass, Zillow got upset, basically, (3:44) with realtors or brokerages (3:48) having pre-listings off-market listings (3:51) because Zillow just reposts, basically, (3:54) for lack of a better word, (3:56) reposts listings off of the MLS.(3:58) So if it’s not on the MLS, (4:00) Zillow cannot repost those listings. (4:04) Therefore, Zillow cannot get clicks (4:09) and charge realtors and lenders leads (4:13) for leads off of those clicks. (4:15) So Zillow’s mad that Compass (4:17) has a lot of off-market listings.(4:19) So then Compass did their private exchange (4:23) just as a, you know, we’re going all in, right, on that. (4:28) So that’s kind of like the snowball effect (4:29) of the last couple of years (4:30) that has really happened, right? (4:32) Yeah. (4:33) So what is your take now? (4:35) Because now this is basically (4:38) like two massive new trade groups, if you will.(4:43) Yeah, I mean, it kind of seems like, (4:47) so if you’re, you have to decide, (4:51) if you’re going to sell a house, (4:52) do you, are you better suited (4:55) to do the private exclusive with Compass (5:01) or to be exposed to a larger group of potential buyers, (5:07) but it’s still kind of in one of the other ecosystems, right? (5:13) At least until it goes live, (5:16) until it goes live on the MLS. (5:19) Right. (5:20) Now, does this create, I mean, is it, (5:26) does it still create a need for NAR’s MLS system? (5:31) Because- (5:32) And the snowball effect might continue, right? (5:35) Yeah.(5:36) So the nuts and bolts of it, (5:39) so the private exclusive for Compass, (5:42) that is only Compass agents, Compass, (5:46) I think it’s Anywhere Real Estate, (5:48) any of their subsidiaries, (5:51) those are the only agents can see (5:53) what’s in the private exclusive, is that right? (5:55) Only agents. (5:55) That’s how I understand it, yeah. (5:57) Okay.(5:57) It’s specific to their group, which is- (5:59) And only agents, not like an open website (6:04) that anyone can browse. (6:06) No, you have to, only the realtors (6:08) that are part of that group can look at it. (6:10) That’s how I understand it.(6:12) Okay. (6:12) And then eventually stuff can get pushed live to the MLS, (6:15) if it’s like, we want to list it in two weeks (6:18) or something like that. (6:18) Yeah, it’s so that they can test certain prices (6:22) without accumulating days on market.(6:27) Right. (6:30) But- (6:31) Yeah. (6:32) From what I understand reading some of the stuff (6:35) about Open Real Estate, and now Open Real Estate, (6:37) the other four major companies, (6:41) and they’re saying anyone can enroll, (6:43) any brokerage can enroll.(6:45) And it’s supposed to be released at some point (6:47) in the first quarter of 2027, (6:49) is that it is a, like their open letter, (6:54) it’s basically says, (6:55) it is a national residential real estate (6:57) data sharing initiative, (6:59) built on the belief that home listing access, (7:01) information and transparency should be a benefit, (7:05) not a barrier to anyone looking to purchase or sell a home. (7:09) So, you know, there are four principles. (7:12) Number one, expand buyer opportunity.(7:13) So this leads me to believe that it’s going to be, (7:17) it’s a more transparent marketplace is what they say. (7:20) Anybody, you and I can hop online to openrealestate.com (7:24) or whatever that is, ends up being, (7:27) and browse homes, whether they’re on the MLS or off market, (7:32) as long as they are within Open’s ecosystem. (7:39) So this is a, not just the realtors, (7:44) but it’s, it provides another incentive to maybe, (7:50) like you said, have it pre-listed.(7:54) And you said, maybe get a sense for what the marketability is (7:58) or the price point is before having actual days on market. (8:04) That’s pretty, that’s pretty, (8:07) it’s powerful in this market right now, (8:11) where it’s a massive buyer’s market (8:14) and sellers are have to have, (8:15) having to very much think about how they list their home, (8:22) listing it correctly, (8:24) because if it’s listed too high right now in this market (8:26) and the house is not a really, really desirable house, (8:32) then it sits and it has to be reduced, you know? (8:35) I, you know, I’m curious, (8:37) I’d be curious to talk to some of these agents (8:39) that are currently in, you know, (8:44) and have clients with houses in the private exclusive (8:48) to see what percentage of these houses are, you know, (8:52) from people who maybe don’t have to sell. (8:56) I bet there are a lot of them that put it out there (8:59) and say, you know, if I’m going to sell, I want 600.(9:03) And then they- (9:06) There are. (9:06) The feedback comes back and is like, no, (9:08) you should be at like 520. (9:10) Right.(9:11) So they’re not going to sell. (9:12) There are a lot of brokerages that do, (9:15) they all do this. (9:17) Obviously the bigger the brokerage, (9:20) the more they can do this, (9:22) but there are a lot of brokerages (9:24) and a lot of brokerages that are luxury focused, (9:30) you know, those do a lot of off-market (9:36) within their brokerage kind of deals.(9:39) Like the house got a contract put together (9:42) while it was being prepared to be listed (9:44) and never got listed because they matched up a buyer (9:48) and a seller within their brokerage. (9:49) And because the brokerage is focused on luxury (9:52) and that’s kind of a luxury option a lot of times too. (9:57) Yeah.(9:57) Is yeah, I got a $4 million house, (9:59) got a $2.5 million house and I’ve got a buyer here (10:01) and it works out that way. (10:04) So that happens a lot internally. (10:07) And now, so now it just, it expands, (10:12) it expands that option.(10:14) But then the neat thing that I think (10:16) they’re talking about, (10:17) and they did say on their calls, (10:20) they had the four CEOs had several interviews. (10:24) And on one of the interviews, (10:25) they said that they’ve had a lot of registrations (10:29) or inquiries. (10:30) I don’t know if they register yet, (10:32) but they inquire how to do this.(10:34) So I could see this first mega benefit (10:38) that I could see would be for smaller boutique shops, (10:45) boutique brokerages that like the idea of being, (10:48) I’m in my community, I’m, you know, whatever, (10:51) any, anywhere, any town USA brokerage, right? (10:55) And we got 50 agents or something. (10:58) Now they can put it, put something pre-listed (11:01) and have every single Keller Williams agent (11:04) in their area see that listing. (11:06) That’s pretty powerful for a smaller boutique shop.(11:11) Yeah. (11:13) And they did say that, yeah, (11:15) like they would work together on this, (11:18) but it’s to kind of expand the, (11:23) it’s to keep everything more transparent, (11:24) but it’s definitely something that could be useful (11:27) for an agent that prefers that boutique shop, (11:32) a smaller shop, but they get this benefit (11:36) of this massive off-market listing service. (11:41) So that’s a really big benefit on that side.(11:47) I think too, another thing that I kind of thought about, (11:51) cause dealing with a lot of veterans (11:53) and then having some realtor partners (11:57) that work with firefighters a lot, (11:59) is a lot of those people, (12:01) they don’t want their information shared. (12:05) You know, maybe you’re very high ranking in the military, (12:09) you know, pilot, something like that. (12:11) You’re a firefighter or a police officer, (12:13) you’re a detective, you are exempt (12:16) from having your information shown (12:17) on the county websites and all that.(12:20) So I could see this being a major help (12:22) for sellers who really don’t want, (12:25) that would prefer to have their listing private (12:29) or kept private as long as possible. (12:33) Yeah. (12:36) Cause you’re opening up your house (12:38) to a whole lot more buyers now through this platform.(12:42) Either one really, Compass or this new one. (12:47) Yeah. (12:48) See, it really helps for, (12:52) it helps the agents who, you know what? (13:00) It helps the agents who will now take a listing (13:04) that they otherwise might not (13:06) because the seller wants too much for their house.(13:10) So like, let’s say a seller says, (13:13) I want $650,000 for my house. (13:16) And the agent says, sir, with all due respect, (13:19) it’s worth 560. (13:21) Right, right.(13:22) I can’t take it at 650. (13:24) That’s gonna be a waste of my time and money. (13:26) Well, now you can take it and say, (13:28) hey, we’re gonna throw it into private exclusive.(13:30) We’re gonna throw it into this environment at 650. (13:34) We’re not gonna accumulate days on market. (13:36) Now we get to see what it’s, (13:38) what people actually think it’s worth.(13:40) Right, right. (13:41) That’s a good, yeah. (13:43) It’s a dry run while still being listed, if you will.(13:48) Still, yeah. (13:48) Yeah, while still taking the listing. (13:52) Because that is, those are conversations (13:53) that have to be had.(13:56) And I’ve heard that from agents. (13:58) If we don’t get any offers, you wanna list for that, okay. (14:02) But if we don’t get any offers by, you know, (14:05) within two weeks, you agree, we are doing this.(14:08) We are lowering it to what I think it should be listed for. (14:11) We’re gonna lower it to this amount (14:12) and continue to lower it until the market tells us (14:16) what the right price is, whatever that is, right? (14:18) So, yeah. (14:23) What was the third, (14:29) there was a very savvy thing that you found.(14:33) Is the seller better served, right? (14:35) Oh yeah, is the seller better served (14:37) by privately testing a listing, a listing price (14:42) or by exposing the property (14:43) to every possible buyer immediately? (14:47) So. (14:48) Right, yeah. (14:48) So that’s the debate, (14:53) which one would be better? (14:56) I mean, I tend to think the private exclusive thing (15:02) is for unique properties, specific properties.(15:08) You know, if it’s a normal house, like 98% of houses, (15:14) it’s probably better served to be exposed (15:16) to as many buyers as possible. (15:19) Everybody right away, right. (15:20) Yeah, I mean, that’s my thought, (15:22) but maybe there’s some of this that I’m not thinking of.(15:25) No, I agree. (15:26) I agree because it could be a situation (15:29) where the house is gonna go pretty quickly. (15:34) And instead of, maybe we do put it on private exchange (15:40) or on open real estate right away (15:44) before everything’s completely done.(15:46) Maybe we’re doing some updates and whatnot. (15:48) And we take some very quick, (15:50) but professional, but quick photos (15:53) and put it on the private market real quick. (15:57) And you could get a buyer right away.(15:59) Yeah. (16:00) Yeah, like you said, a unique property. (16:02) It’s an amazing property.(16:04) It’s gonna go fast no matter what. (16:05) And now it is more convenient for the seller, right? (16:10) Maybe the seller is not having to go through (16:12) all of the stuff that they normally go through (16:15) to get a house ready for sale. (16:17) And then maybe a buyer is also happy (16:19) because they came across a property (16:23) that came before it became available (16:26) on the actual MLS.(16:27) Even though it’s in a pretty massive network anyway. (16:32) So, yeah. (16:35) Well, this is funny.(16:36) So Compass, this is what this says. (16:39) This is a Compass report that they argue (16:42) that sellers benefit from more control (16:45) over their listing information (16:46) and the ability to refine pricing (16:48) before full public exposure. (16:50) Okay, that makes sense.(16:52) But then they also go on to say (16:54) that they have an analysis claiming (16:56) a 4.6% higher closing price. (17:01) Now, how they determine that, (17:03) I don’t know if they’re not counting the reductions. (17:08) Right.(17:10) Are they? (17:11) Right, yeah. (17:13) Based on what methodology? (17:14) They can manipulate that however they want. (17:16) Right.(17:17) We reduced our prices less than the industry average. (17:22) Maybe that’s what it is. (17:23) Maybe, yeah.(17:25) Yeah, which, I mean, (17:28) let’s just, for argument’s sake, (17:31) say that that is accurate. (17:34) Let’s say that that is an accurate data point (17:38) that they have provided. (17:40) Then that bolsters the argument (17:43) of the private listing, (17:48) feel it out.(17:49) And then when you actually go to market, (17:51) you have a better idea (17:52) and actually list it for the proper amount. (17:57) That bolsters that argument. (18:02) Yeah, we’ll see.(18:03) I think this is pretty interesting though, (18:05) this whole scenario. (18:07) So let’s get to the most interesting part, (18:10) the final, where the snowball (18:12) kind of turns into an avalanche, (18:15) is you have the largest single real estate firm (18:21) in Compass and all its subsidiaries. (18:24) And then like you said, (18:25) numbers two through five, (18:27) joining forces on the other end, (18:31) creating their own Zillow (18:37) or realtor.com, if you will.(18:39) Right. (18:41) And if they’re putting their listings (18:45) in to this private marketplace first, (18:48) and then they grow enough, (18:51) like I think that you mentioned it (18:52) at the beginning of the pod, (18:56) does this mean that the MLS (18:59) is even necessary anymore? (19:04) I mean, it would seem kind of repetitive. (19:08) Yeah, it is repetitive.(19:14) Especially with this open real estate platform. (19:19) Yeah. (19:19) Opening, open, open.(19:21) Yeah. (19:22) Opening it up to any brokerage (19:25) that wants to sign up. (19:27) Which I mean, what’s stopping you, (19:31) if you’re a smaller broker, (19:33) or any size brokerage really, (19:35) what’s stopping you from joining this group? (19:38) Right, what if you’re a big broker (19:40) of mom and pop shop? (19:43) Yeah, if you got five agents (19:44) or you got 500 agents, (19:46) but you’re your own group, (19:48) what’s stopping you from joining this? (19:51) Correct.(19:51) I don’t know. (19:52) And maybe we’re not thinking of certain things (19:54) that make sense, (19:58) but it’d be interesting to talk (20:00) to some realtors about this. (20:02) Yeah, yeah.(20:03) Once they actually, (20:04) because I checked with a couple today (20:05) and they were like, (20:06) what are you talking about? (20:08) It’s that new. (20:09) It’s literally that new, right? (20:11) They will hear about it over the next week. (20:13) They announced it yesterday.(20:15) And so I’m sure that in the team meetings (20:18) that happened this week with Keller Williams (20:20) and AXB and Remax Real, (20:23) that they’ll have some more information (20:27) for their realtors, right? (20:29) But yeah, when you really get down to it, (20:32) the MLS is just a source. (20:37) It’s an auto trader, if you will, right? (20:39) It’s a, where can I go online for the buyer, (20:44) for the buyer? (20:46) Where can I go online to look at houses? (20:49) And Zillow is de facto just reposting with the MLS posts. (20:54) So then if you have an open real estate platform (20:59) that encompasses a massive number of big and small shops (21:05) that all put their listings within that system, (21:09) does it negate the need for the MLS (21:12) and then the need for them and the local MLSs (21:21) to continue to pay dues to NAR? (21:27) Yeah.(21:27) I mean, I think we’ll find out here (21:31) in the next couple of years. (21:32) Yeah, right. (21:34) We will, we definitely will, right? (21:36) Because right now all of these realtors (21:37) are basically operating by what like (21:42) National Association of Realtors recommends (21:45) as far as their representation agreements, all that stuff.(21:49) And then obviously what each individual state’s laws are. (21:56) So now would you operate by just based on state law (22:02) and then how legal guidance (22:04) within your own firm recommends, right? (22:06) So would it be a little more localized (22:09) on that kind of stuff too? (22:11) We’ll see. (22:12) So it’s definitely, when I saw these reports, (22:19) these articles this morning, (22:22) honestly, this is the kind of stuff (22:25) that I was expecting to start happening (22:28) after the NAR representation lawsuit, (22:35) after that was all, the dust was settling off of it.(22:38) This is the kind of stuff that I was thinking (22:40) would start happening is we’re replacing (22:44) a big national organization (22:46) with either our own private listings (22:49) or private services or state-based, (22:53) more state-based listing services (22:59) that we would see. (23:01) That’s what I was expecting after that, (23:03) as the dust continues to settle. (23:04) So, but if nothing else, (23:08) I think this is a good thing for buyers and sellers.(23:11) Yeah. (23:12) Yeah, to have that extra option. (23:15) Couple of options, yeah.(23:16) Yeah, yeah, absolutely, 100%. (23:18) So we will see, we will see. (23:21) If we have any realtors that have feedback, (23:24) we definitely wanna hear what they’re saying (23:26) and how they think it’ll affect, benefit or hinder (23:30) the process in buyers and sellers (23:33) and in this whole, (23:36) this new platforms that we have going on or coming out.(23:41) So, all right. (23:43) Nice. (23:44) That’ll be good.(23:46) Yeah, it’s interesting, man. (23:49) Yeah.

This is the first hour of our TREC continuing education course.

Mortgage Markets Class (TREC course 39644-RECE) is 2 hours of approved elective credit for licensed Texas agents, taught live at your office. Same material, in depth, with your team's questions answered in the room.

See the course